Cell Signal Booster vs Satellite Internet: Who comes out on top?
Posted on 9/23/2024 by Blake Marshall
Cell Signal Booster vs Satellite Internet: Who comes out on top?
Discover how the weBoost Drive RV II stacks up against satellite internet giant Starlink.
Wi-Fi or cell signal? It’s the age-old question, and one that has become even more important as more of us are trying to seek solitude while still being connected to the world.
Satellite internet providers like Starlink have soared in popularity in recent years, promising high speed internet connection in even the most remote places, but is it the right solution for your trips out yonder?
While you can’t boost Wi-Fi signal where it doesn’t exist, you can boost even the faintest cell signal to get more bars in more remote locations. See how our weBoost Reach RV II stacks up against Starlink to settle the Wi-Fi vs. Cellular debate for off-grid adventures.
Service
In simplest terms, Starlink is an internet service provider, while weBoost amplifies the cell service that you’ve already signed up for. So, if you are only looking for a Wi-Fi connection Starlink may give you what you’re looking for.
weBoost amplifies cell signal to make the most of your current cell phone plan, allowing you to make calls and send text messages with confidence without needing a Wi-Fi connection. And if all roads lead to the internet, and you’re choosing the route, weBoost gives you noticeably more flexibility, with faster data speeds to do things like check email and stream your favorite shows.
Price
In today’s world, having a cell phone is all but mandatory. Since we’ve collectively adopted the technology already, why not use it to its maximum potential?
With weBoost, a one-time purchase of $549 is all it takes to boost your existing cell signal. The best part? No subscription. Just install and start amplifying your signal.
Pricing for satellite internet from Starlink, on the other hand, starts at $599 and can cost as much as $2500. And that’s just for the hardware. On top of that, monthly subscription fees range from $50 a month to $165, meaning annual fees can surpass $2,000.
And, if wear and tear is a concern for you, weBoost offers a two-year warranty on the Reach RV II, whereas Starlink only offers a one-year warranty.
Price
Because weBoost boosts available cell signal, the data usage is simply leveraging whatever data plan you currently have in place. That means that weBoost doesn’t throttle your data speed, and uses existing 4G, 5G, and LTE networks anywhere in the US.
Starlink’s base plan has a 50GB data limit, and you pay-per-gig for any overages. For an added fee, you can opt for unlimited data per month. Their data infrastructure leverages private satellites, and using Starlink outside your defined service area requires an additional monthly fee.
Access
The question between satellite internet, like Starlink, and a cell signal booster like weBoost ultimately comes down to “does it work” and “how well does it work.”
For Starlink to give you the Wi-Fi you’re looking for, it needs to be manually aligned with its source. So, you’ll need to move it occasionally to pick up the best signal. And, if you are roughing it where tree cover is dense, you’re going to have a tough time getting a connection. Other potential connection losses include inclement weather and trying to use it while in motion.
weBoost is designed to amplify the cell signal that already exists around you and amplifies it, instead of trying to acquire a new connection. So, if you’ve got one bar in a dense forest or driving down a lonely stretch of road, weBoost can boost it, even while you’re moving. And our hexagon omni-directional antenna design means no manual alignment.
Hardware
Comparing hardware and set up is critical when deciding between satellite internet and a cell signal amplifier.
weBoost comes with hardware included for permanent installation for a set-it-and-forget-it signal booster on your RV. Power consumption is at a minimum, averaging less than 20 watts when in use. And weBoost is tough as nails, using weather-resistant components tested to military standards (MIL-STD-810G) for shock and vibration. With an average lifespan of 8-10 years, weBoost will be ready for every adventure.
Starlink can be installed permanently, but due to the design, it can cause major drag on your vehicle. There may be some level of set up required each time Starlink is used. Aside from drag and frequent set up, Starlink is a power guzzler, needing between 40-150 watts when in use—often requiring a generator to power.
When deciding between satellite internet and a cell signal booster like weBoost, it comes down to getting more signal in more remote areas—and getting the most out of the data plan that you already use every day.
Side-by-side comparison between weBoost and Starlink
weBoostDrive Reach RV II | Starlink | |
Cellular Signal Booster | Wi-Fi Service | |
Cellular signal | Yes | No |
Wi-Fi signal | Via mobile hotspot | Yes |
Price | $549 | $599-$2500 |
Monthly subscription fees | $0/mo. | $50-165/mo.* |
Yearly cost | $0/year | $600-$1980/year subscription cost |
Data usage | Leverages your current data plan | 50GB data limit with pay-per-gig; unlimited available for additional fee |
Speed/data throttling | No | Yes |
Plan adjustments | No plan required | Upgrade option; zero downgrades for life of plan |
Areas of use | Anywhere in the U.S. | Requires additional monthly fee |
Infrastructure leveraged | Existing 4G, 5G, LTE networks | Private satellites |
Amplifies existing signal | Yes | No |
Works in dense tree cover | Yes | No |
Works in motion | Yes | Possible signal interruptions during motion |
Permanent installation | Yes, hardware included | Available; may cause significant drag |
Impacted by weather | No | Yes |
Manual alignment required | No | Yes |
Power consumption | Average < 20 watts | 40-150 watts, may require generator |
Warranty | 2 years | 1 year |
Hardware lifespan | 8-10 years | Unknown; untested |
Years in business | 24 years | 5 years |
Set up | Install once, boost forever | May require set up for each use |
Privacy & security | Secure cellular connection | Based on user |
Known outages | 0 | Recent outage Recent outage |